Mexicans Are Now New York City's Fastest Growing Ethnic Group
New data from the U.S. Census reveal that Mexicans are New York City's fastest growing ethnic group. New York City's Mexican population ranked 11th among major U.S. cities in 2000 at 186,872, a figure that rivals the size of long-standing Mexican communities like San Diego, Santa Ana, and San Jose, California. Yet, the data also show that the city's Mexican inhabitants face serious social and economic challenges, according to a study released today by Teachers College, Columbia University.
Using information from the 2000 U.S. Census of Population, the study finds that the average per-capita income of the Mexican population is among the lowest in New York City. The mean household income per-capita of Mexican New Yorkers is $10,231, or less than half the prevailing average of $22,402 for all New Yorkers in 1999. Close to one-third of Mexicans lived in households that were under the poverty line in 2000, more than double the poverty rate in the city overall.
The report also reveals a troubling link between low income and educational attainment. The report shows that the average educational completion of Mexicans in New York is approximately nine years of schooling, compared to thirteen years for New Yorkers overall. In addition, Mexican teenagers have the lowest high school retention rates in New York.
The author of the report - The State of Newyorktitlan: A Socioeconomic Profile of Mexican New Yorkers - is Francisco Rivera-Batiz, Professor of Economics and Education at Teachers College, Columbia University.
Mexicans had the highest rate of population growth of all the major racial and ethnic groups in New York City in the 1990s. The number of Mexican New Yorkers counted by the U.S. Census more than tripled, from 61,772 in 1990 to 186,872 in 2000. But the Census data likely reflect a substantial undercount of the total number of Mexicans living in New York. More inclusive estimates place this population in the range of 275,000 to 300,000.
Mexicans have grown to constitute the third largest Hispanic/Latino group in New York, after Puerto Ricans and Dominicans. More than 60 percent of all Mexican New Yorkers reside in Queens and Brooklyn, although there are significant populations in the Bronx and in Manhattan. Within Brooklyn, the neighborhoods of Sunset Park and Bushwick have major Mexican populations. In Queens, Elmhurst, North Corona and Jackson Heights have the highest concentrations of Mexicans, and East Harlem hosts Manhattan's largest Mexican community.
Immigration is the largest source of the Mexican population growth in New York. Close to 80 percent of Mexican New Yorkers were born outside the U.S. Mexican migration to New York City - of both legal immigrants and undocumented workers - rose in the 1980s and 1990s, as it did in other parts of the country. But the flows to New York became denser, as Mexican migration became increasingly diversified geographically during the 1990s.
Most Immigrants Come from Rural Areas Near Mexico City
The place of origin of most Mexican immigrants in New York is the State of Puebla, a prominent industrial and commercial region located south and east of Mexico City. Estimates are that between 60 and 80 percent of all Mexican migrants in New York City originate in Puebla or in other states in the rural vicinity of Mexico City, including Guerrero, Jalisco, and Michoacan. Most of these migrants come from low-income, rural communities within these states.
"Intricate and intimate migrant networks have developed over the years between NewYork City and specific communities in Puebla and other neighboring states in Mexico," says Francisco L. Rivera-Batiz. "As family members and friends from these communities move back and forth between the two countries, they facilitate the flow of information. The result is that news about employment opportunities in New York are quickly transmitted to potential workers in Mexico."
Mexican New Yorkers Are Mostly Young and Unskilled
The median age of the Mexican population in New York City is 24.3 years, compared to 34.4 years for the city overall. Mexican New Yorkers also have very low levels of schooling by U.S. standards: close to 60 percent of the population aged 25 years or older had not completed high school in 2000. By comparison, less than 30 percent of the overall New York City population had less than a high school education.
The relatively low educational attainment of Mexicans in New York is partly explained by the low schooling of Mexican migrants. Among adults, close to one-third of Mexican immigrants in New York have achieved only elementary school education. But the educational quagmire is compounded by the low school retention rate among Mexican teenagers. For instance, the citywide enrollment rate for persons 18 to 19 years of age was 67.6 percent for males and 71.2 percent for females in the year 2000. But among Mexican teenagers the corresponding figures were only 25 percent and 31.1 percent, respectively.
Youth and low schooling have severely restricted the Mexican workforce's job opportunities. Mexican migrants, in particular, have generally been successful in securing only highly unskilled jobs in New York, mostly in manufacturing, construction and the service sector. Mexican men have a special niche in the food services and food retail industries, where as much as 42 percent of all Mexican male workers in New York are employed. In some jobs in this sector, the Mexican presence is palpable: 20 percent of all men employed as cooks and food preparation workers in New York are Mexican.
Many Contend with Low Wages, Poverty, Exploitation
The highly unskilled employment niches where many Mexican laborers thrive are also low-earnings sectors. For some workers, labor market discrimination is another force to contend with, particularly among undocumented migrants, who frequently suffer from exploitation in underground labor markets. As a result, the average earnings of Mexican men and women are sharply lower than those of the rest of the New York workforce.
Although the income per-capita of Mexicans is extremely low by New York City standards, the income that Mexican immigrants receive often represents an enormous leap compared to the situation they would have faced in Mexico. Average household income per person in the state of Puebla in Mexico is about 40 percent of that for the average Mexican household in New York. And in the rural communities of Puebla, where many Mexican New Yorkers originate, the average income per capita often lies below $1,000 per year, which is a small fraction of the average annual income per-capita in New York.
But Rivera-Batiz emphasizes that the comparison of the social and economic situation of Mexican New Yorkers with that of other groups in the city is still highly relevant.
"Many Mexicans residing in New York today will remain in the city for a long time, if not a lifetime. As a result, their economic well-being and that of their children is linked to New York," says Rivera-Batiz. "The challenges faced by Mexicans in New York, in the areas of education, labor and working conditions, as well as in the immigration area, must be seriously considered by policymakers. Ignoring them would undermine the valuable contributions that are being made by Mexicans to the city."
Teachers College is the largest graduate school of education in the nation. It is affiliated with Columbia University, but it is legally and financially independent. The editors of U.S. News and World Report have ranked Teachers College as one of the leading graduate schools of education in the country. For more information about Teachers College, please visit our Web site at www.tc.columbia.edu.
Francisco Rivera-Batiz can be reached for comment on the report and its findings through Mr. Rosen at 212-678-3176.previous page