2011 TC Research
Teachers College, Columbia University
Teachers College Columbia University

Research

Section Navigation

Judith M. Burton

Professional Background

Educational Background

National Diploma in Design, Hornsey College of Art, London; Academic Diploma in Education, University of London; M.Ed., University of Manchester; Ed.D., Harvard University

M.Ed. Thesis: Innovation in Art Education at the Secondary Level in France and England: A Comparative Study.
Ed.D. Thesis: Lines, Space, and the Organization of Meaning in Human Figure Drawings Made by Children Eight to Fifteen Years.

Scholarly Interests

Artistic-aesthetic development in children and adolescents.

Learning, and transfer of learning in the arts.  Instructional methods in the arts. Role of artists in the education of children.  Cultural experiences in arts education.


Selected Publications

Burton, J.M. & Hafeli, M. (Eds.), (due Fall 2009). Conversations in Art:  The Dialectics of Teaching and Learning. Reston, VA: NAEA.

Burton, J.M., (Due Fall 2009). Guide for Teaching and Learning in the Visual Arts.

Burton, J. M.  (2007). Conversations Across Cultures.  In Al Hurwitz, Memory and Experience, Reston, VA: NAEA Press.

Burton, J.M.  (2006).  Drawing in the Service of the Mind. In Rolf Niehoff and Rainer Wenrich (Eds).  Thinking and Learning with Images. Munich, Germany: Kopaed.

Burton, J. M.  (2006). The Integrity of Personal Experience, or the Presence of Life in Art.  International Journal of Arts Education. 3.2.

Burton, J.M., (2004).  The Practice of Teaching: Devices and Desires .In Elliot Eisner, and Michael Day, (Eds.).  The Handbook of Research and Policy in Art Education. Reston, VA: National Art Education Association.

principal publications

Books:

Lowenfeld, V. and Burton,J.M., (due spring 2003). Creative and Mental Growth. 3rd.,Edition Revised. New York: Prentice Hall

Burton, J.M., (Ed.). Conversations in Art: The dialectic of Teaching and Learning. Discussion with Various Publishers.

Burton: J.M., (1999). The Ziegfeld Collection: International Artworks of Adolescents from the 1950s. A Celebration. New York: Teachers College Columbia University.

Burton, J.M. (1999). A Guide to Teaching and Learning in the Visual Arts. Unpublished Manuscript, Teachers College Columbia University New York.

Burton, J.M., London, P., and Lederman, A.(1988) (Eds.). Beyond DBAE: The Case for Multiple Visions of Art Education. New York:University Council on Art Education.


Chapters:


Burton, J.M., (2001). Doctoral Programs at Teachers College. In James Hutchins, (Ed.). In Their Own Words: The Development of Doctoral Study in Art Education. Reston, VA: National Art Education Association.

Burton, J.M., (2000). Edwin Ziegfeld: A Humanistic Legacy. In, Sylvia Corwin (Ed.). The Legends of Twentieth Century Art Education, An Historical Review. Reston, VA: National Art Education Association.

Burton, J.M., Horowitz, R., and Abeles, H., (1999). Learning in and Through the Arts: Curriculum Implications. In. Ted Fisk (Edi.). Champions of Change. Washington, DC: Arts Education Partnership.

Burton, J.M., (1996). Natural Allies: Children, Teachers and Artists. In, Jane Remer (Ed.).

Beyond Enrichment. N.Y: American Council on the Arts, Publication.

Burton, J.M., (1994). Art Education and the Plight of the Culture. In Al Hurwitz and Otfried Scholtz (Edis.).Art Education in the United States of America Berlin, Germany: Hochschule Der Kuenste,.

Burton, J.M., (1993). Emerging Americans: The Painter Speaks. Introductory Chapter. In, Joan Jeffri (Ed.). The Painter Speaks, Westport, Connecticut: Greenwood Publishing Group, Inc.

Burton, J.M.,(1993). Trends and Issues in Visual Arts Education Curriculum. In,Visual Arts Teacher Resource Handbook. New York: Kraus International Publications.

Burton, J.M., (1988). Aesthetics in Art Education. In, Judith M. Burton, Peter London, and Arlene Lederman (Edis.). Beyond DBAE: The Case for Multiple Visions of Art Education. New York: University Council on the Arts.


Papers/Articles:


Burton, J.M., (2000). The Configuration of Meaning: Learner Centered Art Education Revisited. Studies in Art Education, 41 (4).

Burton, J.M. Horowitz, R., and Abeles, H.,(2000).Learning in and Through the Arts: The Question of Transfer. Studies in Art Education, 41 (3).

Burton, J.M., (1999.) Materials and the Embodiment of Meaning. In, Jo-Anna Moore (Ed.). Crafts and Education, Haystack. Deer Isle, ME: Haystack Mountain School of Craft.

Burton, J.M., (1996). Briefing Paper on Student Learning in and Through the Arts. In, Edith Zimmerman, (Ed.). Briefing Papers: Creating a Visual Arts Research Agenda Towards the 21st Century. Reston, Virginia: National Society for Education Through Art.

Burton, J.M., (1995). The Arts in Infancy: Celebrating Artistry in the Child.
In, Al Hurwitz (Ed.). The Arts in Infancy. Baltimore, Maryland: Maryland College of the Arts Press.

Burton, J.M., (1994). The Arts in School Reform: Other Conversations. Teachers College Record, Vol. 95, No. 4.

Burton, J.M., (1992). Art Education and the Plight of the Culture: A Status Report. Art Education, Spring.

Burton, J.M., (1991. Some Basic Considerations About "Basic Art". Art Education, July.

Burton, J.M., (1990). Marino Marini: A Personal Response. IL Tremisse Pistoise, 15, N. 2-3.

Burton, J.M., (1990). The Aesthetic Presence of Truth: A Response to Rudolph Arnheim. New Ideas in Psychology, Fall.

Burton, J.M. Putting It All Together: Clay in Secondary Education. Studio Potter, Vol. 16, No. 2, June 1988.

Burton, J.M. ,(1986). Once More With Feeling: The Discipline of Art/The Art of Discipline. In Thomas Ewans (Ed.). Discipline and Art Education. Providence, RI: Rhode Island School of Design, 1986.

Burton, J.M., (1981). Developing Minds: With Three Dimensions in View. School ArtsVol. 80, No.5, January.

Burton, J.M., (1980). Developing Minds: Representing Experience From Imagination and Observation. School Arts, Vol. 80, No. 4, December.

Burton, J.M., (1980). Developing Minds: Visual Events. School Arts, Vol. 80, No. 3, November.

Burton, J.M., (1980). Developing Minds: The First Visual Symbols. School Arts, Vol. 80, No. 2, October.

Burton, J.M. (1980) Developing Minds: Beginning of Artistic Language. School Arts, Vol. 80, No. 1, September.

studio

Maintaining a studio practice has threaded in and out of my teaching, writing and research these past years, apparently idiosyncratic, yet on reflection, not so!. I was originally trained as a painter and had the good fortune to study with Maurice deSausmerez, one of the most eminent painting teachers working in Great Britain in the 1960s. From him I acquired a great respect for the hand, the physical gesture, the mark, and the dynamics of its presence on a surface. As I now reflect on things, this, perhaps, is not surprising, as drawing has been at the center of my art practice since I was a child. For me drawing was and still is a private place, another world, in which to follow where my imagination leads. I think I have always drawn, and still do. For sometime now my drawings have taken the form of what one might call elaborate doodles, activations of surfaces: lines pushing, pulling and floating behind and in front of the flat paper. My drawings begin and go where they will, and only slowly do the lines come into relationships that hint at meanings, little messages that are multiply layered, each building on the other. I think these kinds of drawings call upon what I have termed ‘Sensory Logic’ in my more theoretical writings. They also refer to my abiding interest in the many and different ways in which we can explore the representation of the third dimension on the flat surface.

My sense is that the activity of the hand and body in consort with material provides part of the loop we call artistic intelligence, perhaps intelligence itself. We know that knowledge at its profoundest originates in and remains rooted to our bodily and emotional sensibilities. My fear is that as technology moves us further and further from actions on and with materials, and as we acquire more and more information, we will at the same time denude knowledge of its human meaning. Technology provides us with fantastic new tools, it is now up to us in arts education to use them with imagination to enrich what is central to all the arts—their humanness; the possibility they offer us all to stretch across time, space, and cultural differences and meet each other in human enterprise and community.

teaching

As I look back to the beginning of my teaching in a comprehensive secondary school in London, England, I see a set of concerns that have shaped the work I do. I remember only too vividly the young adolescent who said to me in my first year of teaching "I don’t like art and you can’t make me do it!" and another who said "show me how to make my drawing look real."

Over the ensuing years I have struggled to understand how, and for what reason, we can make art education compelling in young people’s education at a time when learning itself becomes problematic. I have also sought to ponder on the difference between my own sensibility as a trained artist and the experiences brought to artistic practice and appreciation by young people of different ages. Where does artistry come from, what is its trajectory and outcome? What is ''real'' anyway and why does this pose such critical questions for human experience, culture and art? Why do some of us feel so profoundly that art is important to life?

Out of such ponderings emerged a belief that we can, and should, educate teachers to reflect thoughtfully on their own artistic insights, be sensitive to and insightful about human development in general and in the arts specifically, and be able to translate the former into supports for the latter. Within this conception of education I also place personal agency and cultural knowledge, for it is imperative that teachers take in hand their own on-going learning and research for through this that they remain alive and young people in schools are empowered to inherit the artistic accumulations of history. Personal agency is also founded in relationship, and a growing sense of professionalism. For if we treat each other with respect and caring, as partners in a complex enterprise, if we practice professional integrity, then art education stands a chance of remaining a humanistic enterprise.

My own teaching reflects these concerns as they have been shaped over the years and as they continue to be shaped—both as a teacher and teacher educator. Each year, through work with an extraordinary vital faculty, wonderful doctoral students in research, and lively minded master students preparing to teach, my own thinking and practice move forward in many and surprising ways!

Judith teaches seven courses at Teachers College

biographical information

Judith Burton is Professor and Director of Art and Art Education, Columbia University Teachers College. Before that she was Chair of Art Education of Boston University and taught at the Massachusetts College of Art.  She received her Ed. D. from Harvard University in 1980. Her research focuses on the artistic-aesthetic development of children and adolescents and the implications this has for teaching and learning.  In 1995 co-founded the Center for Research in Arts Education at Teachers College, and in 1996, she founded the Heritage School a comprehensive high school featuring the arts, located in Harlem, NYC.  She is author of numerous articles and chapters and currently has three books in process of publication: She received the Manuel Barkan Award for excellence in research writing, and the Lowenfeld Award for lifetime achievement in art education from NAEA. Dr, Burton is a Fellow of the Royal Society for the Arts in Great Britain, a Distinguished Fellow of the NAEA, and serves as Distinguished Visiting Professor at the Central Academy of Fine Arts Beijing, China. She is also a Trustee of the Maryland Institute College of Art, Baltimore, MD.

research

My research interests of late center on a number of factors contributing to the artistic development of children, adolescents and young adults in college. Studies have included examination of such questions as: how teachers ''read'' and respond to children''s art works, how children and adolescents themselves respond aesthetically to paintings, how children’s artistic thinking extend to other disciplines and the role of professional artists in stimulating learning in the arts. In essence, my research interests relate to gaining deeper insight into the emergence and continuous development of visual symbolic capacities, and the factors that both promote and inhibit this journey. I am concerned to know more about how acts of artistry shape individual’s relationships with the world, the relationship between artistic thinking and aesthetic responding, and the mediating role played by the culture.


Recent Projects:

Investigation of the relationship of learning in and through the arts to other subject disciplines in K-12 schools.   

Investigation of the sources of image making in the art-making practices of early adolescents (funded).

Investigation of the role of professional artists working in schools.

Investigation of the aesthetic responses of children, adolescents and adults to mature works of art: fine and material culture.

honors and awards

A&HA 4080: Artistic development of children

Corequisite A&HA 4281. Required of all candidates seeking New York State art teacher certification (K-12). Recommended for all degree candidates in elementary education. An examination of the role of the senses, emotions, and intellect in artistic development and of the layered integrations they form over time. Discussion of ways in which developmental insights are basic to the design and implementation of exemplary visual arts lessons and offer critical starting points for research. Special fee: $30.

A&HA 4087: Processes and structures in the visual arts

Suggested for all students in all degree programs. Opportunity for in-depth and sustained exploration of the properties, structures, and expressive uses of selected art materials. The course aims to enrich and extend personal visual repertoires and in parallel, provoke insights into the role of materials in supporting, integrating and challenging the artistic growth of young people in school. Special fee: $75.

A&HA 4088: Artistic development: Adolescence to adulthood

Corequisite A&HA 4281. An examination of sensory, biological, affective, cognitive, and cultural issues influencing continuing development in the visual arts. Discussion of ways in which developmental insights are basic to designing challenging lessons which enrich growth and learning as well as offering critical starting points for research. Required of all candidates seeking New York State Art Certification K-12. Special fee: $30.

A&HA 4202: Fieldwork in art education

Permission of instructor required. Professional activities in the field under faculty supervision.

A&HA 4902: Research and independent study in art education

Permission of instructor required. Professional activities in the field under faculty supervision.

A&HA 5202: Fieldwork in art education

Permission of instructor required. Professional activities in the field under faculty supervision.

A&HA 5902: Research and independent study in art education

Permission of instructor required. Professional activities in the field under faculty supervision.

A&HA 5922: Master's seminar in art education

Corequisite A&HA 6202. Permission of instructor required. Required for all M.A. and Ed.M. students. Guided independent work in research, culminating in the development of a masters proposal. Special fee: $30.

A&HA 6202: Fieldwork in the art education

Permission of instructor required. Professional activities in the field under faculty supervision.

A&HA 6482: Internship in the teaching of college and museum programs

Permission of instructor required. Guided experiences in the teaching of the arts in departments of metropolitan area colleges. Sections: (1) Teaching art programs: college, (2) Teaching art programs: museum.

A&HA 6972: Research and independent study in art education

Permission of instructor required. Research and independent study under the direction of a faculty member.

A&HA 7502: Dissertation seminar in art education

Two required tutorial sessions for doctoral students to help develop or refine topics of inquiry for research. The teaching format is flexible and may include faculty/student presentations, group discussions and critiques. May be repeated. Section 2 is required of all doctoral students in the program in the semester following successful completion of written certification papers and involves preparation and presentations of dissertation proposal for approval. Sections: (1) Certification preparation, (2) Dissertation proposal preparation.

A&HA 8900: Dissertation advisement in art education

Individual advisement on doctoral dissertations. Fee to equal 3 points at current tuition rate for each term. For requirements, see section in catalog on Continuous Registration for Ed.D. degree.

Centers and Projects

Center on Chinese Education
Website: http://www.tc.columbia.edu/centers/coce/

The Center on Chinese Education, Teachers College Columbia University (CoCE) is aimed at contributing to a better understanding of education in China and to educational exchange between the United States and China. It seeks to achieve this mission through three categories of activities: research and development, education and training, as well as outreach and exchange. These activities will draw upon the historically special relationship between Chinese education and Teachers College, the interests and expertise of the faculty at Teachers College, as well as expertise and resources outside of Teachers College. Major funding for the Center's activities is provided by the Henry Luce Foundation and the Ford Foundation.

Contact: Mun C. Tsang
E-mail: mct27@columbia.edu



Judith M. Burton appeared in the following articles:

Looking Beyond The Frame (6/26/2013)

Celebrating All Things 125 (6/25/2013)

President's Letter (6/25/2013)

Telling the TC Story (3/11/2013)

TC's Juan Carlos Reyes Featured on NPR's "American Dreams: Then and Now" (6/6/2012)

Making the Case for Art Education (5/15/2012)

Home Is Where the Art Is (5/14/2012)

A Group of TC Faculty Condemns the Release of Teacher Evaluations Based on Student Test Scores (3/8/2012)

2010: The Year in review (5/11/2011)

Staff news (3/29/2011)

TC At Work: Juan Carlos Reyes (12/17/2010)

Playing to the Gallery (12/8/2010)

TC Remembrances (12/8/2010)

Dedicating the Cowin Center and Honoring Its Benefactor (6/24/2010)

Curtain Up! (5/20/2010)

Joining Forces (5/20/2010)

A Festival of Leaders (4/29/2010)

A Tribute to Joyce Cowin (4/29/2010)

TC Campus News (3/26/2010)

A Patron of TC Art (6/1/2009)

Masters of Art (3/24/2009)

November Calender of events (11/1/2008)

What is the Role of the Arts in 21st Century Schools? (5/8/2007)

Honoring an Arts Educator (2/22/2007)

Macy Gallery Grows Up (1/22/2007)

Alumni Awards (12/13/2006)

Kidspace Opens It's Elementary at MASS MoCA (10/4/2006)

Re-Imagining New Orleans (9/20/2006)

TC and China: The Second Century (9/20/2006)

Kelvin Sealey: Breaking New Ground (4/24/2006)

A Timeline of Growth and Change: Arthur E. Levine's Presidency at Teachers College (9/14/2005)

TC Gives Students Voice Through Art Exhibit (8/5/2005 1:57:40 AM)

TC Education Zone Partnership Unites College’s Collaborations with City Schools (6/9/2005)

A Campaign for Equity: In the Neighborhood (6/1/2005)

The Next Big Thing (4/12/2005)

Art for a Few? (3/28/2005)

Where Teachers Are Made (2/23/2005)

Where Teachers Are Made (2/23/2005)

In the Vanguard of the Small School Revolution (2/2/2005)

Eye of the Beholder (1/13/2005 4:35:26 PM)

National School Arts Conference Highlights Success of Small East Harlem School (11/24/2004)

Framing The Arts (10/13/2004)

The Art of Balance (10/13/2004)

Class Notes (6/1/2004)

Exploring Fat Attitudes (3/30/2004)

A Picture Is Worth A Thousand Words: Arts Education in New York City Schools (9/30/2003)

Improving Practice in Education (8/1/2003)

Preparing the Next Generation of Leaders in Education (8/1/2003)

Leadership of Central Academy of Fine Arts in Beijing Visits TC (2/1/2003)

Arts Education Conference at the Heritage School (1/1/2003)

International Conversations Through Art (10/1/2002)

Rob Horowitz: Arts Education Promotes Intellectual Development (4/1/2002)

Christo and Jeanne-Claude: The Art of Gentle Disturbance (3/1/2002)

TC on the Move and at Home (1/1/2002)

Faculty Briefs (7:4) (12/1/2001)

Postcards To New York (11/1/2001)

Colonel Myers: The Art of Giving (6/1/2001)

Faculty Briefs (5/1/2001)

Burton Delivers Lowenfeld Lecture at NAEA Convention — Burton, Abeles, and Horowitz Receive the Barkan Memorial Award (3/1/2001)

The Heritage School: A Model Extended Day Program (1/1/2001)

Partners in Pressing for Reforms in Education (4/1/2000)

Teachers College: A Leader in Educating Leaders (1/1/2000)

Looking back and looking ahead: Founders Day (11/1/1999)

Master's Degree Graduates Highlighted for Achievements (6/1/1999)

Shifting the Arts Debate from One-Way Transfer of Skills To the General Development of Critical Thinking Abilities (6/1/1999)

Heritage School Wins $375,000 Grant For After-School Programs (11/1/1998)

Maxine Greene: The Arts and Shaping a Social Vision (12/16/1997)

Professor Burton to Chair NAEA Task Force (12/16/1997)

Where Are They Now? A Listing of Departmental Hubs (1/15/1997)

Museum, Awake! (1/1/1900)