Are Schools Really Getting Better at Getting Better for Black Kids? Maybe, Sorta Kinda
There is a continuous improvement movement in education where schools are supposedly getting better at getting better. Educators are engaging in rapid cycles where they identify problems, design solutions, test whether the solutions work, and spread working solutions. The research brief, Improving Black Education: The Pitfalls and Possibilities of Continuous Improvement in Schools, is guided by two questions, is continuous improvement really happening, and even more importantly, is it making a difference for Black children. In the words of my Black, teenage twins, “maybe, sorta kinda . . . it depends.” Despite my intention to use this brief to uncover and provide a definitive “yes” or “no” answer, the truth is grayer than that.
Continuous improvement has taken its place among an array of educational reform efforts designed to improve the educational quality experienced by marginalized youth. Supported by initiatives from the Gates Foundation and the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching, continuous improvement broadly, and improvement science specifically, has been taken up by educators all over the country. With historical roots in industry, which had aims of increasing production, educators and scholars alike have questioned if continuous improvement can be adapted to serve the justice-oriented and human-centered enterprise of schooling.
I have been teaching continuous improvement and writing about it for over ten years. I have always framed my writing around its possibilities and what justice-oriented individuals could accomplish if they engaged in collaborative continuous improvement with an aim of liberation. Possibility and prophetic imagination must be balanced with truth and reality. We must examine what is happening and not solely what we want to happen. Despite its laudable goals of closing gaps and its intentions of organizing and galvanizing educational professionals to hone their craft to transform educational systems for the better—we have to ask the question-- does it work?
The answer to that question is maybe, sorta kinda; it depends. Research shows us many educators using continuous improvement are not fully engaging in it. It is hard to determine how effective something is if the use of it is incorrect or inconsistent. For example, if the doctor prescribes blood pressure medicine but a patient does not take it consistently, it is hard to determine the effect of the medicine on the patient’s blood pressure. This is often the case with continuous improvement; cycles are started but not completed; educators design solutions but fail to test if they work. However, research does show when educators engage fully the outcomes for students, including Black students, are better. So, whether or not continuous improvement is impacting students depends on the extent to which educators are engaging in that work.
Is there evidence of clear impacts of continuous improvement on Black student outcomes? Sorta kinda. Data indicate that even when improvement efforts target Black student success, the impact on Black students is often not distinguishable from other groups. If its impacts are equally felt, it may not be so useful for closing gaps. Moreover, continuous improvement is about leveraging the resources and expertise that already exist in an organization; it does not address resource inequities which are a key contributor to inadequacies in Black education. So, continuous improvement may impact student outcomes but it cannot destabilize societal inequalities that contribute to Black children’s different educational opportunities.
Framing an honest conversation on continuous improvement around its pitfalls and possibilities, this brief reminds readers that continuous improvement is a tool, not a remedy, for pursuing liberatory education for Black children. Furthermore, as a tool, its power is in the hands of those who wield it. For continuous improvement to realize its potential for changing the experiences and outcomes for Black children, those of us who love Black children must be involved in defining the problems that plague educational systems, designing the solutions that serve Black children, and determining what better really means for Black education. Schools won’t get better at getting better for our kids without us being engaged in the improvement.
Improving Black Education: The Pitfalls and Possibilities of Continuous Improvement in Schools
This research brief examines the pitfalls and possibilities of continuous improvement for Black students. The brief argues that continuous improvement is not a remedy, but a tool for justice-minded individuals pursuing a vision of schooling that does not yet exist for most Black children.
Behind the Brief with Dr. Brandi Hinnant-Crawford
In this short video, Dr. Hinnant-Crawford argues that whether continuous improvement truly serves Black children depends entirely on who is holding the tool, as it can only transform outcomes when rooted in the values, goals, and ingenuity of Black people.
About the Series
From Possibility to Praxis: Reclaiming the Power of Reflection and Action in Black Education. This series features the work of our inaugural cohort of BERC Research Fellows - a distinguished cadre of mid-career educational leadership and policy scholars from across the country dedicated to strengthening Black education through relevant research and policy advocacy.
About the Author
Brandi Hinnant-Crawford, Ph.D., is a self-described motherscholar, critical pragmatist, and liberation theologian. She currently serves as the John and Deborah Bardo Distinguished Professor of Educational Leadership at Western Carolina University. Crawford’s scholarship focuses on equity and inclusion for marginalized students across the P-20 pipeline as well as how research, particularly improvement science, can be leveraged as methodological tools to catalyze just outcomes. Her work has been published in diverse venues such as Black Liberation Theology, Urban Education, Educational Researcher, the International Journal of Teacher Leadership, and the Interdisciplinary Journal of Problem Based Learning. In her 2020 book, Improvement Science in Education: A Primer, she reconceptualizes improvement by centering equity and justice as the purpose of improvement. She asks scholars and scholar practitioners to consider equity not only as an outcome of improvement but to ensure equity in the process by continuously asking who is involved (who is defining the agenda, who is given decision making authority) and who is impacted (who benefits and who bears the burden of the work).
Dr. Hinnant-Crawford holds a doctorate in philosophy from Emory University in Educational Studies, a master’s degree in Urban Education Policy from Brown University, and bachelor’s degrees in English (with teacher licensure) and Communication (media concentration) from North Carolina State University. From the time she first stepped foot in the classroom in the rural south to working in central office in the urban north to conducting research across the county, she has been committed to providing equitable opportunities to learn for all children. Dr. Hinnant-Crawford seeks to do the work her God and her soul require, her ancestors approve, and her children deserve. Dr. Hinnant-Crawford serves as a research fellow for the Black Education Research Center.